Table of Contents
- Understanding Crypto Loss Write-Offs
- The IRS and Crypto: New Reporting and Rules
- Tax-Loss Harvesting Strategies for 2025
- Short-Term vs. Long-Term Capital Gains/Losses
- Beyond Basic Sales: Theft, Abandonment, and Other Losses
- Essential Record-Keeping for Crypto Investors
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The world of cryptocurrency is exciting, but it also comes with tax implications that can be complex. As we head into 2025, understanding how to leverage crypto losses for tax benefits is more important than ever. This guide will break down the strategies and regulations you need to know to navigate crypto tax write-offs effectively and potentially reduce your tax burden.
%2C%20professional%20photography%2C%20high%20quality%2C%20detailed%2C%208k%20resolution%2C%20beautiful%20lighting%2C%20vibrant%20colors?width=1200&height=800&nologo=true&seed=1761930849874&token=2ek2PA2fUN_K4EZB)
Understanding Crypto Loss Write-Offs
The IRS treats cryptocurrency as property, not currency. This fundamental classification means that when you sell, trade, or otherwise dispose of your digital assets, you trigger a taxable event. Just like selling stocks or real estate, these transactions can result in either a capital gain or a capital loss. The good news for investors is that these realized capital losses can be a powerful tool for tax reduction. They can be used to offset any capital gains you might have from other investments, whether it's other cryptocurrency sales, stocks, bonds, or even NFTs. This strategic offsetting is often referred to as tax-loss harvesting.
If your total capital losses for the year exceed your total capital gains, you can deduct a portion of the remaining net loss against your ordinary income. For the 2025 tax year, this annual limit remains $3,000 per individual or $1,500 if married filing separately. Any net capital loss beyond this $3,000 threshold doesn't disappear; it gets carried forward to future tax years. This carryforward provision is incredibly valuable, allowing you to use those past losses to reduce your tax liability in subsequent years without any time limit, provided you continue to have net capital losses.
It's crucial to understand that only realized losses count. Holding an asset that has decreased in value doesn't provide a tax benefit until you sell it. The act of selling crystallizes the loss, making it available for tax purposes. Therefore, carefully timing your sales of underperforming assets can be a key component of your tax planning strategy.
For example, imagine you bought 1 Ether (ETH) for $4,000 and its value has dropped to $2,500. You haven't realized a loss for tax purposes yet. However, if you sell that ETH for $2,500, you've realized a $1,500 capital loss. This $1,500 loss can then be used to reduce your taxable gains. If you had a $5,000 capital gain from selling Bitcoin and a $1,500 loss from selling ETH, your net taxable capital gain would be reduced to $3,500.
Key Concepts in Crypto Loss Reporting
| Term | Definition | Tax Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Capital Loss | When you sell a crypto asset for less than its cost basis. | Can offset capital gains; up to $3,000 deductible against ordinary income annually. |
| Taxable Event | Selling, trading, or spending cryptocurrency. | Triggers capital gains or losses that must be reported. |
| Loss Carryforward | Unused capital losses that can be applied to future tax years. | Reduces future tax liabilities indefinitely. |
My opinion: Understanding the nuances of how crypto is treated as property is the first step towards effective tax planning. It’s empowering to know that losses aren't just losses; they can be strategic tools to mitigate your overall tax burden.
The IRS and Crypto: New Reporting and Rules
The IRS is significantly increasing its focus on cryptocurrency reporting, and 2025 marks a notable shift. A key development is the mandatory introduction of **Form 1099-DA** by the IRS. Starting January 1, 2025, cryptocurrency exchanges and digital asset brokers will be required to report gross proceeds from customer sales and exchanges directly to the IRS. This form is designed to bring crypto reporting in line with how traditional securities are handled, enhancing transparency and compliance.
The implications of Form 1099-DA are substantial. It means the IRS will have direct access to data about your crypto transactions, making it harder to overlook or misreport gains and losses. For the 2026 tax year, Form 1099-DA is expected to include cost basis information as well, further streamlining the IRS's ability to cross-reference reported figures and detect discrepancies. This increased visibility underscores the necessity for meticulous record-keeping on the part of the investor.
Another significant development to monitor is the potential extension of the **"wash sale" rule** to cryptocurrencies. Currently, this rule, which prevents taxpayers from claiming a loss on a security sold and repurchased within a short period (typically 30 days), does not apply to digital assets. However, there is considerable discussion and proposed legislation in Congress that could change this. If enacted, it would fundamentally alter how tax-loss harvesting is conducted in the crypto space, requiring investors to be more strategic in their timing and asset selection to avoid disqualifying their loss deductions.
The IRS also continues to consider income generated from activities like mining, staking, and airdrops. These are generally treated as ordinary income at the time of receipt and are reported on Schedule 1 or Schedule C, depending on the nature of the activity. Understanding these distinctions is vital, as income from these sources is taxed differently than capital gains from selling assets.
Upcoming Reporting Changes
| Change | Effective Date | Impact on Investors |
|---|---|---|
| Form 1099-DA (Gross Proceeds) | January 1, 2025 | Increased IRS visibility into crypto sales. |
| Form 1099-DA (Cost Basis) | Expected for Tax Year 2026 | Further direct reporting of cost basis by exchanges. |
| Wash Sale Rule Extension | Proposed legislation (watch for updates) | Potential restriction on immediate repurchase after selling at a loss. |
My opinion: The IRS's move towards more standardized reporting for crypto is a natural progression. Investors who embrace these changes and maintain accurate records will be best positioned to navigate tax season smoothly and avoid potential scrutiny.
Tax-Loss Harvesting Strategies for 2025
Tax-loss harvesting is a sophisticated strategy that involves intentionally selling cryptocurrency assets that have depreciated in value. The primary goal is to realize capital losses that can then be used to offset capital gains realized from other profitable trades. This process is crucial for managing your tax liability effectively. For example, if you have a significant capital gain from selling Bitcoin at a profit, you can strategically sell other crypto holdings that are currently trading at a loss to reduce the amount of taxable gain.
The key to successful tax-loss harvesting lies in understanding the rules surrounding the repurchase of assets. Currently, without the wash sale rule applying to crypto, an investor could theoretically sell a cryptocurrency at a loss and immediately buy it back. This allows them to realize the loss for tax purposes while maintaining their position in the asset. However, if the wash sale rule is extended to crypto, this loophole will close. Investors would need to wait a specific period, typically 30 days, before repurchasing the same or a substantially identical asset, or they would need to purchase a different, non-substantially identical asset to avoid invalidating the loss deduction.
Another aspect of tax-loss harvesting involves optimizing your cost basis tracking. Your cost basis is the original value of your cryptocurrency, including any transaction fees. Accurately calculating this is essential for determining your actual profit or loss. For instance, if you bought 1 Bitcoin for $30,000 and paid $100 in fees, your cost basis is $30,100. If you later sell it for $25,000, you have a realized loss of $5,100.
Different methods exist for identifying which specific coins you are selling when you have multiple purchases of the same cryptocurrency at different times. These include First-In, First-Out (FIFO), Last-In, First-Out (LIFO), and Highest-In, First-Out (HIFO). While you can currently choose a method, the IRS will mandate FIFO for cost basis reporting starting in 2026. This means it's wise to start tracking your basis using a method that aligns with FIFO or to be prepared for the transition. For tax-loss harvesting, HIFO can sometimes be advantageous as it allows you to harvest losses from your most expensive coins first.
An investor might have purchased 5 units of Coin X at $10/unit and another 5 units at $5/unit. Their total cost is $75. If Coin X is now trading at $4/unit, selling all 10 units would result in a $35 loss ($75 cost - $40 proceeds). If they were to use HIFO to harvest losses, they would sell the 5 units bought at $10, realizing a $30 loss ($50 cost - $20 proceeds), and still hold the 5 units bought at $5. This allows them to strategically realize larger losses sooner if their goal is immediate tax reduction.
Tax-Loss Harvesting: Key Considerations
| Strategy Element | Description | 2025 Implications |
|---|---|---|
| Realize Losses | Sell depreciated crypto assets. | Offset capital gains, up to $3,000 against ordinary income. |
| Wash Sale Rule | Rule preventing immediate repurchase after selling at a loss. | Currently not applicable to crypto, but proposed for future. |
| Cost Basis Identification | Methods like FIFO, LIFO, HIFO. | FIFO mandated from 2026; HIFO can maximize immediate loss harvesting. |
My opinion: Tax-loss harvesting is a proactive approach that can significantly impact your net tax liability. Being aware of the potential wash sale rule changes is critical for planning future strategies.
Short-Term vs. Long-Term Capital Gains/Losses
The distinction between short-term and long-term capital gains and losses is fundamental to how your crypto profits and losses are taxed. This distinction is based on the holding period of the asset. If you held a cryptocurrency for one year or less before selling it, any profit is considered a short-term capital gain, and any loss is a short-term capital loss. If you held it for more than one year, profits are long-term capital gains, and losses are long-term capital losses.
The tax rates applied to these categories differ significantly. Short-term capital gains are taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, which can be as high as 37% for the highest earners in 2025. This means that short-term gains can be quite costly from a tax perspective. Conversely, long-term capital gains are taxed at much more favorable rates: 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your overall taxable income. This preferential treatment for long-term gains incentivizes holding assets for extended periods.
When it comes to offsetting gains with losses, the IRS has specific rules: short-term losses first offset short-term gains. If there are remaining short-term losses, they can then be used to offset long-term gains. Similarly, long-term losses first offset long-term gains. Any remaining long-term losses can then offset short-term gains. If, after all offsetting, you still have a net capital loss, you can deduct up to $3,000 ($1,500 if married filing separately) against your ordinary income, with the rest carried forward.
For example, suppose in 2025 you have: * A $10,000 short-term capital gain from selling Dogecoin. * A $6,000 short-term capital loss from selling Shiba Inu. * A $4,000 long-term capital gain from selling Bitcoin. * A $2,000 long-term capital loss from selling Ethereum.
Here's how the netting process works: 1. Short-term netting: $10,000 (STCG) - $6,000 (STCL) = $4,000 net STCG. 2. Long-term netting: $4,000 (LTCG) - $2,000 (LTCL) = $2,000 net LTCG. 3. Overall netting: You have $4,000 net STCG and $2,000 net LTCG. Since net STCG and net LTCG are both positive, they are added together to form your total net capital gain. Your total taxable capital gain for the year would be $6,000.
Now, let's change the scenario slightly: * A $10,000 short-term capital gain from selling Dogecoin. * A $15,000 short-term capital loss from selling Shiba Inu. * A $4,000 long-term capital gain from selling Bitcoin. * A $2,000 long-term capital loss from selling Ethereum.
1. Short-term netting: $10,000 (STCG) - $15,000 (STCL) = -$5,000 net STCL. 2. Long-term netting: $4,000 (LTCG) - $2,000 (LTCL) = $2,000 net LTCG. 3. Overall netting: Your net STCL of $5,000 can now offset your net LTCG of $2,000. This leaves a remaining net STCL of $3,000 ($5,000 - $2,000). 4. Deduction against ordinary income: You can deduct $3,000 of the remaining net STCL against your ordinary income. The final $1,000 net STCL ($3,000 - $3,000) is carried forward to the next tax year. In this case, your total taxable capital gain is $0, and you've also reduced your ordinary income by $3,000.
Holding Period and Tax Rates
| Holding Period | Gains Tax Rate (2025 est.) | Losses Offset |
|---|---|---|
| One Year or Less (Short-Term) | Ordinary Income Rates (up to 37%) | First offset short-term gains, then long-term gains. |
| More Than One Year (Long-Term) | Preferential Rates (0%, 15%, 20%) | First offset long-term gains, then short-term gains. |
My opinion: The difference in tax rates between short-term and long-term gains is a significant incentive for long-term investing. For tax-loss harvesting, realizing short-term losses can be particularly effective if you have short-term gains to offset.
Beyond Basic Sales: Theft, Abandonment, and Other Losses
While most crypto investors think of losses stemming from market downturns, other types of losses can also be deductible under specific circumstances. The IRS allows deductions for losses incurred due to theft or abandonment of cryptocurrency, though these are subject to stricter rules and require thorough documentation. Understanding these less common scenarios can provide additional avenues for tax relief.
Theft Losses: If your cryptocurrency is stolen, for example, through a hack of your exchange account or a personal wallet, you may be able to claim this as a casualty loss. However, the IRS has specific requirements for casualty and theft loss deductions. Generally, these are only deductible if the loss occurred in a federally declared disaster area, which is rare for crypto theft. More commonly, theft losses are treated as capital losses if the crypto was held as a capital asset, meaning you'd report it on Form 8949 and Schedule D. The key challenge is proving the theft and its timing, which often requires extensive evidence, such as police reports, exchange investigation summaries, or forensic analysis of your wallet.
Abandonment Losses: If you intentionally abandon a cryptocurrency, you might be able to claim an abandonment loss. This occurs when you permanently give up all rights to an asset without receiving or expecting any compensation. For example, if you lose the private keys to a wallet containing crypto and there's no reasonable prospect of recovery, you might consider it abandoned. To claim this, you need to demonstrate a clear intent to abandon the asset. The IRS typically views this as a sale or exchange, resulting in a capital loss equal to your cost basis. Documentation is critical here too, to show the event that led to the abandonment and your intent.
Lost or Erased Private Keys: Similar to abandonment, if you lose access to your crypto wallet due to lost private keys and cannot recover your funds, this loss is generally treated as a capital loss. It's not a direct deduction against ordinary income unless it fits within the $3,000 net capital loss limit. The loss is realized when you can definitively prove that the asset is irretrievably lost and you have no hope of future access. This is often established by the passage of time and the inability to recover the keys through any available means.
Worthless Assets: In rare cases, a cryptocurrency might become completely worthless, for instance, if its underlying project fails entirely and the coin has no market value or utility. If you can demonstrate that the asset has become worthless during the tax year, you can claim a capital loss equal to your basis in that asset. Proving worthlessness often requires showing that the asset has no market value and no prospect of future value, which can be challenging in the volatile crypto market. For example, if a project you invested in declares bankruptcy or its network is permanently shut down, and the token becomes untradable and valueless, you might have grounds for claiming it as worthless.
Types of Crypto Losses Beyond Market Swings
| Loss Type | IRS Treatment | Documentation Needs |
|---|---|---|
| Theft | Generally Capital Loss | Proof of theft (e.g., police report, exchange records). |
| Abandonment | Capital Loss (loss equals basis) | Demonstrate intent to abandon and cessation of rights. |
| Worthless Asset | Capital Loss (loss equals basis) | Proof of worthlessness and no market value/utility. |
My opinion: Recognizing that losses beyond simple market depreciation can be tax-deductible is a crucial insight for crypto investors. The emphasis on documentation for these types of losses cannot be overstated.
Essential Record-Keeping for Crypto Investors
In the realm of cryptocurrency, accurate and comprehensive record-keeping is not just good practice; it's a necessity for tax compliance. With the IRS stepping up its oversight and the introduction of new reporting forms like 1099-DA, having your financial house in order is paramount. The complexity of crypto transactions—spanning multiple exchanges, wallets, and trading pairs—can make this challenging, but it's where the magic of tax write-offs truly lies.
At a minimum, you need to track each cryptocurrency transaction. This includes the date of acquisition, the date of disposition, the type of cryptocurrency, the quantity involved, the fair market value in U.S. dollars at the time of the transaction, and the cost basis. For sales and exchanges, you also need to record the proceeds received. For trades of one cryptocurrency for another, the fair market value of both cryptocurrencies at the time of the trade is essential for determining gain or loss.
Given the upcoming changes, especially the mandated FIFO cost basis reporting from 2026 and the 1099-DA from 2025, utilizing crypto tax software or robust spreadsheets is highly recommended. These tools can help aggregate transaction data from various sources, calculate cost basis using different methods, and generate the necessary reports for filing. Relying solely on memory or basic exchange statements is unlikely to be sufficient, especially as your portfolio grows and transactions become more numerous.
For those engaging in more complex activities like mining or staking, records should include details about the income received (fair market value at receipt), any expenses incurred (like electricity, hardware depreciation), and the cost basis of any mined or staked coins. This detailed information is crucial for accurately reporting income and any associated deductions on your tax returns.
The importance of proper documentation cannot be stressed enough. If the IRS audits your return, your records will be your primary defense. They not only support your reported gains and losses but also help in substantiating any claims for deductions, such as theft or abandonment, which require proof. Without meticulous records, claiming crypto losses could lead to penalties or disallowed deductions, negating any potential tax benefits. Therefore, making record-keeping a priority from the outset will save significant time, stress, and potential financial penalties down the line.
Essential Crypto Transaction Data to Record
| Data Point | Description | Importance for Tax Purposes |
|---|---|---|
| Date of Transaction | When the acquisition or disposition occurred. | Determines short-term vs. long-term holding period; essential for IRS reporting. |
| Type of Crypto | e.g., Bitcoin, Ethereum, Altcoin Name. | Distinguishes assets for basis tracking and tax reporting. |
| Quantity | Amount of crypto transacted. | Crucial for calculating gains and losses. |
| Cost Basis | Original value + fees. | Essential for calculating taxable gains or deductible losses. |
| Proceeds from Sale | Value received in USD (or equivalent). | Used to calculate profit or loss against cost basis. |
My opinion: The transition to more robust reporting requirements means that meticulous record-keeping is no longer optional. It's the bedrock upon which all tax-loss harvesting and accurate reporting are built.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. What is a taxable event in cryptocurrency?
A1. A taxable event occurs whenever you sell, trade, or spend your cryptocurrency. This includes trading one cryptocurrency for another, selling crypto for fiat currency, or using crypto to purchase goods or services.
Q2. How do crypto losses offset gains?
A2. Realized capital losses from cryptocurrency sales can offset capital gains from any asset class. Short-term losses first offset short-term gains, and long-term losses first offset long-term gains. Any remaining net losses can then offset the other category of gains.
Q3. Can I deduct unlimited crypto losses?
A3. No, you can deduct up to $3,000 of net capital losses against your ordinary income per year. Any losses exceeding this amount can be carried forward to future tax years.
Q4. What is the wash sale rule and will it apply to crypto in 2025?
A4. The wash sale rule prevents you from claiming a loss on a security sold and repurchased within 30 days. While it doesn't currently apply to crypto, there's proposed legislation that could extend it. Stay updated on this potential change.
Q5. What is cost basis and why is it important?
A5. Cost basis is your original purchase price plus any associated fees. It's crucial because it's used to calculate your capital gain or loss when you sell an asset.
Q6. What is Form 1099-DA?
A6. Form 1099-DA is a new IRS form that will require cryptocurrency exchanges and brokers to report gross proceeds from customer sales and exchanges to the IRS, starting in 2025.
Q7. Will Form 1099-DA include cost basis information?
A7. Yes, it is expected that Form 1099-DA will include cost basis information for tax year 2026, further enhancing IRS reporting capabilities.
Q8. What are short-term and long-term capital gains?
A8. Short-term gains are from assets held for one year or less and are taxed at ordinary income rates. Long-term gains are from assets held for over a year and are taxed at lower preferential rates.
Q9. Can I deduct losses from stolen crypto?
A9. Yes, in some cases, but it's complex. Generally, theft losses are treated as capital losses and require substantial proof. It's best to consult a tax professional.
Q10. What is tax-loss harvesting?
A10. Tax-loss harvesting is a strategy where you sell investments that have lost value to realize capital losses, which can then be used to offset capital gains and reduce your tax liability.
Q11. How do I report crypto gains and losses?
A11. Crypto gains and losses are typically reported on Form 8949 and Schedule D of your tax return. Mining or staking income is usually reported on Schedule 1 or Schedule C.
Q12. What happens to unused capital losses?
A12. Unused net capital losses can be carried forward indefinitely to future tax years to offset future capital gains and, if applicable, up to $3,000 against ordinary income annually.
Q13. Does trading crypto for another crypto create a taxable event?
A13. Yes, trading one cryptocurrency for another is considered a disposition of property and therefore a taxable event, potentially triggering capital gains or losses.
Q14. What is the FIFO rule for cost basis?
A14. FIFO (First-In, First-Out) is a method for calculating cost basis where you assume the first units of crypto you acquired are the first ones you sell. The IRS will mandate this for crypto reporting from 2026.
Q15. Can I use HIFO for tax-loss harvesting?
A15. Yes, you can use HIFO (Highest-In, First-Out) to strategically realize larger losses sooner, though the IRS will require FIFO reporting starting in 2026. It's important to maintain accurate records for whichever method you use.
Q16. What are the potential penalties for misreporting crypto taxes?
A16. Penalties can include fines, interest on underpaid taxes, and even criminal prosecution in cases of intentional evasion. The IRS uses data from exchanges to identify discrepancies.
Q17. How do I calculate the cost basis for crypto I received from mining or staking?
A17. The cost basis for mined or staked crypto is its fair market value in U.S. dollars at the time you receive it. This value is also reported as ordinary income.
Q18. What is an abandonment loss for crypto?
A18. An abandonment loss occurs when you permanently give up your crypto without receiving compensation, such as when private keys are lost permanently. It's treated as a capital loss equal to your basis.
Q19. Do I need to report every single crypto transaction?
A19. While the IRS requires reporting of all gains and losses, the complexity of tracking can be managed. Using crypto tax software that aggregates transactions is highly recommended to ensure all taxable events are captured.
Q20. How can I find a tax professional specializing in crypto?
A20. Look for Certified Public Accountants (CPAs) or Enrolled Agents (EAs) who explicitly list cryptocurrency tax expertise on their websites or professional directories. Many online tax software platforms also offer access to such professionals.
Q21. If I use crypto for purchases, is it a sale?
A21. Yes, using cryptocurrency to buy goods or services is treated as selling that crypto for its fair market value in U.S. dollars. This creates a taxable event where you realize a capital gain or loss.
Q22. What is the difference between Form 8949 and Schedule D?
A22. Form 8949 is where you list the details of each capital asset sale or disposition. The totals from Form 8949 are then summarized and transferred to Schedule D, which calculates your net capital gain or loss.
Q23. Are there any crypto gains that are not taxed as capital gains?
A23. Yes, income from mining, staking rewards, and crypto received through airdrops are generally treated as ordinary income at the time of receipt, not capital gains.
Q24. What if I received crypto as a gift? How is its cost basis determined?
A24. If you receive crypto as a gift, your cost basis is generally the same as the donor's basis. However, if the fair market value at the time of the gift is less than the donor's basis, your basis for determining a loss is that fair market value.
Q25. Can I claim losses from NFTs?
A25. Yes, NFTs are treated as property by the IRS, similar to cryptocurrency. Therefore, losses from selling NFTs can be reported and used to offset capital gains.
Q26. What if my exchange goes bankrupt? Can I claim the loss?
A26. Losses due to an exchange bankruptcy can be complex. They are often treated as capital losses. The IRS provides guidance on how to report such losses, which usually involves demonstrating that the assets are irretrievably lost.
Q27. Are there any crypto transactions that are not taxable?
A27. Generally, simply holding crypto or moving it between your own wallets is not a taxable event. Taxable events arise from selling, trading, or spending.
Q28. How does the IRS track crypto transactions if not reported by exchanges?
A28. The IRS uses various methods, including data analytics, blockchain analysis tools, and information obtained from users through tax forms and audits. The introduction of 1099-DA significantly enhances their tracking capabilities.
Q29. Can I offset gains from stocks with losses from crypto?
A29. Yes. Since both crypto and stocks are treated as capital assets, losses from one can offset gains from the other after intra-asset class netting is complete.
Q30. Is it ever too late to harvest losses for a given tax year?
A30. For realizing losses for the current tax year, you generally need to sell the assets before December 31st. However, losses harvested now can be carried forward to future years.
Disclaimer
This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or tax advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. Consult with a qualified tax professional or financial advisor before making any investment or tax-related decisions.
Summary
Navigating cryptocurrency tax write-offs for 2025 involves understanding how the IRS treats crypto as property, the implications of new reporting forms like 1099-DA, and strategic approaches such as tax-loss harvesting. By accurately tracking cost basis, differentiating between short-term and long-term gains/losses, and maintaining meticulous records, investors can effectively use realized losses to reduce their tax liabilities, including up to $3,000 against ordinary income annually, with unused losses carried forward indefinitely.
📌 Editorial & Verification Information
Author: Smart Insight Research Team
Reviewer: Davit Cho
Editorial Supervisor: SmartFinanceProHub Editorial Board
Verification: Official documents & verified public web sources
Publication Date: Nov 1, 2025 | Last Updated: Nov 1, 2025
Ads & Sponsorship: None
Contact: mr.clickholic@gmail.com
Official Resources
For the most accurate and up-to-date information, please refer to the official IRS website:
No comments:
Post a Comment